Thoughts on home theater projectors being reviewed, related products, and tips for users

Major Error on 1080p Projector Comparison

March 18th, 2008 Art Feierman

Greetings All!

It has been brought to my attention, that the numbers I cited, in this blog, and in the report, relating to the Panasonic rebate, are incorrect:I reported that the new Promotion was going to be $400 mail-in cash rebate, and a $250 Blockbuster rental card. Well it turns out I screwed up. I see now (from the new banners just received from Panasonic’s ad campaign, and a couple of emails from dealers), that the campaign is actually $650, consisting of $400 in Blockbuster rentals, something that many folks will value as being worth far less, and $250 value for an extra year extended warranty! I checked an email received from Panasonic, and it too said that.Unless I were to value the $650 of blockbuster rentals and warranty, as about the same as cash (and I know many don’t like the Blockbuster cards), that should put the Panasonic in the $2000 – $3500 range.

Here’s how I’m going to treat things:

The awards, as they sit, will remain. Afterall, for those that will value the Blockbuster card as useful, and extra year warranty, it could just barely be rationalized that the PT-AE2000U still makes the top of the lower price category.

But more to the point, if I do not leave it there, I need to change the price point, so that I have at least three projectors in the Entry level category, which might mean making the lowest category $2400 and under, or something like that. That would move a couple projectors over, and force me to redo both the Under $2k and $2K to $3500 sections. All that would occomplish is moving back all reviews a couple of weeks. I just don’t have the “strength” to redo it all. Sorry!

I will, however alter some of the text in the report to correct about the rebate, and I will factor in the different rebate, in the current one-on-one comparisions that are in progress right now, including Panny vs Sanyo, Panny vs HC4900, Panny vs. Epson Home Cinema UB, and assign it a different value proposition.This will delay posting them a couple of days, now probably Thursday night when 6-8 comparisons will now post, as as three of the four I have already written, but not posted, involve the Panasonic.

Again, my apologies, for a grave error on my part. I can’t even blame it on Panasonic. I spoke with them, misunderstood, and then didn’t look closely at the email they sent me, which properly stated the program, so the fault is all mine. -art

Share and Enjoy:
  • RSS
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Google Bookmarks
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit

4 Responses to “Major Error on 1080p Projector Comparison”

  1. okay Art, i guess we can allow this one mistake but only this one! and that’s only because your website is so damn fantastic!!! keep up the great work!

    *****

    Gee chris, you’re such a sport!!! Let’s see! 40 reviews a year, a couple of large reports, articles – and you allow me but 1 mistake!
    Tsk! Tsk!

    Truly, would forgiveness for 3-4 mistakes a year be that unreasonable? (that can include when manufacturers lie to me.). thanks -art

  2. Andrew Yang Says:
    March 20th, 2008 at 5:13 pm

    Would you consider the upgrades in the RS1X worth the $500 premium it seems to be commanding? Specifically, are the extended gamma adjustments necessary? Your reviews (and others) seem to imply the out-of-box settings are nearly bang on (with the exception of the extended gamut).

    ******

    I haven’t been following the launch of the RS1x, and haven’t received one yet. So, your comment is the first suggesting what the street price difference is. Personally I would like both key improvements of the RS1x, – better gamma controls, and Deep Color support. I would spend the difference. Deep Color may prove to be something we really want, once we start seeing some content. In the broader sense, the Deep Color support fits into the category of making the “x” more future proof. I would like the gamma controls. The RS1 has little to play with, and gamma is one of those areas I would do some adjustment, not so much for a great blu-ray movie, but for setting up user savables, that meet specific room lighting needs, and maybe for SDTV, and some rather poor SD-DVDs. You sound like someone who may like to play, with the projector, if so, definitely worth it. But even without both, the RS1, is one fine projector. -art

  3. Andrew Yang Says:
    March 24th, 2008 at 12:32 pm

    That was a fast follow-up. Thanks for the insight. Given the discount I’m getting for the RS1U (clearing channel inventory), the premium may end up being closer to $1000 when all is said and done. As much as I might like to play with the projector (and I’ve got an iOne with some software waiting to go) it may be a bit much for “future proofing” and fiddling. Especially given your comments on it being great for Blu-Ray and really only needing the fine tuning for SDTV and poor SD-DVDs. No SDTV for me (all OTA HDTV) and I can tolerate the occasional poor SD-DVD.

  4. Chris Hogan Says:
    April 3rd, 2008 at 6:32 am

    Art – Is the new 1080p projector comparison report now considered complete? The content still says it’s a first pass and a few more comparisons will come, but it doesn’t look like the report has been updated in at least a couple weeks.

    Thanks!

    *********

    Hi, It’s pretty much done! I haven’t looked at it in almost two weeks, as I’ve been traveling and will be for another 12 days. I’m sure there are a few things that I will add, and some things may be “missing”. But I’d say virtually all “critical” info is in there. -a

Leave a Reply