Sanyo PLV-Z4 vs. Panasonic AE900U - Projector Ergonomics
Overview & Image Quality
Image Quality Cont...
Ergonomics
Summary
Lens Shift, Lens
Both of these projectors offer 2:1 zooms. Both have more than enough range to allow the vast majority of users to place the projector a a shelf in the back of their room, if so desired, instead of ceiling mounting or placing it on a table. Lens shift is another issue. Lens shift allows you flexibility in where you place the projector vertically (and horizontally - although that is not normally an issue). With the Panasonic you can place the projector vertically anywhere from slightly above the top of the screen (about 8" to a foot) depending on how the zoom is set), to an equal amount below the screen when on a table.
The Sanyo PLV-Z4 projector has more range in the lens shift. So, for example, if ceiling mounting, you can have it further above the screen (by about a foot) than the Panasonic. This may be a slight advantage in most rooms, but if you have a high ceiling you may really like this advantage. For example, if you have a 12 foot ceiling and the top of your screen surface is at 8 feet, then the Panasonic would have to hang down slightly more than 3 feet, while the Sanyo would only have to be mounted about 2 feet from the ceiling, making it less intrusive (when the lights are on). The WIN goes to the Sanyo PLV-Z4, in this catagory. Also I like the Sanyo's separate controls for vertical and horizontal lens shift, better than Panasonic's joystick combined control. The Sanyo Z4, I should note, (like the Panasonic projector) now has a lens shift lock. Some owners of the older Z3 reported that the lens shift would slip, resulting (if ceiling mounted), in the image moving a few inches up over time, requiring the user to adjust it from time to time (or tape the controls down). This is no longer an issue, with the Sanyo Z4 projector.
Remote Controls
Panasonic's PT-AE900u projector offers a remote with a better layout, and, in fact it's a learning remote that you can program to control your other home theater devices. (I did not review that aspect of the remote.) The Panasonic is fairly long, and controls are well organized with plenty of spacing between buttons. The backlight is nice and bright.
The Sanyo Z4 projector's remote, by comparison is small and more packed in. What really bothered me, though is it seems to have a more limited range. When I test both projectors at my house, I'm sitting about 11 feet from the screen and the projector is about 6 feet behind me. With the Panasonic projector's remote, I had no trouble bouncing the IR signal off of my front wall, and screen to control the projector. With the Sanyo, it was so hard to do that, that I resorted in pointing the projector over my shoulder back to the Sanyo Z4.
Now there are a couple of solutions. First, you may opt for a good programmable remote to control all your devices which then makes the range of the Sanyo's remote a moot point. The other point - If your room and screen are smaller, this may not be a problem at all for the Sanyo Z4 projector's remote. Overall, though The PT-AE900u is the clear winner when it comes to remotes.
Menu Layout
Both home theater projectors have well thought out menu layouts. I found both to comparable. No winner here.
User Manuals
Both are pretty good, both pretty much step you all the controls and most of the features, and both, while listing your options for the many adjustments, don't go into enough explanation as to the advantages, etc. of using many of those choices. In other words both manuals are good, but could be even better.
Interfacing
Both home theater projectors have two component inputs, one HDMI, an S-video, a composite video and a computer input. If ever there was a tie, this is it.
Styling
Sanyo wins this one. The Panasonic looks more industrial, the Sanyo is nicely finished with soft edges. Also the Sanyo has a motorized door that closes, covering the lens when the projector is off. Nice touch, and it keeps dust from collecting on the lens when the projector is off (which of course is 80-90% of the time for most owners.
Lamp Life
Since Sanyo does not rate the life of their lamps, this is a hard one to call. I'll have to play a hunch here, based on dealer feedback on the older Z3 projector. While lamp is rated 2000 hours in full power, many lamps fail long before that time. The Panasonic claims 2000 hours in full power and 2700 in economy mode. That's pretty typical. I suspect that the Panasonic lamp - on average - will last longer than the Sanyo, because I used to hear a fair amount about Sanyo lamps not lasting as long as anticipated on the Z3. Purely guesswork.
Review continues below this advertisement.
Warranty
Sanyo offers a 3 year warranty, parts and labor. Panasonic offers a one year parts and labor warranty. That's a huge advantage for the Sanyo Z4 projector. Panasonic does offer a 2 year extension - bringing it to three years, and dealers typically sell that for $199 (List $250). Factor that into your costs.
There is another difference or two, and that's regarding how warranty works. Notably, Sanyo lacks a DOA policy. If they ship a dealer a defective projector, and it goes to the customer, Sanyo will not replace the unit, only repair it. Panasonic will take back defective product from dealers within the first 30 days after it is sold to a consumer.
The net result, if you get a new unit with a problem from Sanyo, Sanyo will repair it, not replace it. With the Panasonic projector, most dealers will tell you to ship the projector back to them, and will send you another brand new projector (first 30 days). Now some Sanyo dealers may do the same (replace it) for you, but I recommend you check that out with your potential dealer before making a purchase. Because of that no DOA policy by Sanyo, that leaves the dealer with a problem. If they take yours back and replace with a new one, they then have to have the faulty one repaired and sold off as refurbished. And that should force them to sell it for significantly less.
So, I prefer Panasonic's flexibility on defective new units, but Sanyo has the much longer warranty. Take the cost of the Panasonic PT-AE900u's extended warranty into consideration. Since right now (11/05) Panasonic is offering rebates on their AE900u projector, the net selling price is less on the Panasonic. It might be enough less to pay for that extra 2 year warranty.
That notwithstanding, Sanyo's warranty program includes their paying the round trip freight, and turning around the projector at their service facility in 24-72 hours (allow extra time for shipping). Panasonic does not have a guaranteed turn-around time.
Both projectors should be extremely reliable, as were their predecessors.
Noise Levels
Tie: This is a non-issue for both projectors, even in their full power modes, they are very quiet, and virtually silent in low lamp modes. With either you are unlikely no notice noise from either - even if you are sitting within 3 feet of the projector, unless the room is virtually silent (and what do you watch with no sound?).
Overview & Image Quality
Image Quality Cont...
Ergonomics
Summary