JVC DLA-RS1 and Sharp XV-Z20000 Home Theater Projectors: A Comparison Review – Overview

When I did use Brilliant Color, with the Sharp, on hi-def content (Blu-Ray, HD-DVD, and HDTV), I wasn’t impressed, images got a bit “hard” looking (less film-like).  As a result, I stopped using it with such sources.  I will say though, that watching HD sports, with moderate ambient light, Brilliant Color did help.  It might be plus for those with more than the minimum acceptable ambient light.  With my JVC, I can adjust contrast, color saturation, and gamma, for more “pop” as well, but one button operation for what is the equivalent to Vivid on my old 32 inch Sony TV, is a nice touch.

JVC RS1 and Sharp Z20000 – Brightness

In standard, single projector reviews, I normally deal with brightness in the General Performance page, but in comparisons, of late, I prefer to treat brightness as a component of image quality. Why? More often than not, the best cure for image quality being washed out by ambient light, either intentional or otherwise, is simply more lumens.

The JVC, in its best mode (remember, no dynamic iris), is much brighter almost (800 lumens) than the Sharp in its best (just over 250 lumens).  Fortunately for the XV-Z20000, it performs almost identically with their iris set to Medium instead of High Contrast.  This jumps lumens up to 367.  Even the Bright iris setting, and the Sharp still retains very impressive black levels though, set for bright, it definitely comes up rather short, and not in the JVC’s class, on black levels.  With Bright iris setting, the Sharp musters up about 880 lumens (regardless of whether you choose Dynamic, Natural or Standard picture modes.

So, the bottom line in terms of brightness, is that for the Sharp to rival the JVC in black levels and shadow detail, it still needs either High Contrast, or Medium iris modes.  And, in those modes, the Sharp outputs half or less, of the lumens of the JVC in its best mode.

When you need maximum brightness, however, the two projectors are virtually identical in terms of lumens, both close to but not exceeding 900 lumens (based on my measurements).

This difference in brightness when you are looking for every last ounce of image quality for movies, gives the JVC a distinct advantage over the Sharp, especially for those planning on larger screens.  Of course when you want to put on your favorite football game in hi-def, with some light in the room, their brightness becomes a tie!

JVC RS-1 spacecowboys monitorLarge
XV-Z3000 SpaceCowboys MonitorLarge

You May Also Like

News And Comments