Posted on November 6, 2015 Art Feierman
On the home projector side, BenQ was a relatively early pioneer of high quality DLP projectors back in the day (around 2005-2007) when 720p resolution dominated, and we were buying our first PS3’s and other Blu-ray players. Since then, BenQ has perhaps, better than any other company, established their reputation for quality entry level home theater / home entertainment projectors around the $1000 price point here in the US. Over four years ago, BenQ introduced their W1070 one of my all time favorite low cost projectors. BenQ knows a good thing when they have one, which translates into that the W1070 was so well received, that although BenQ has offered newer projectors (including the HT1075) which could be considered “newer, replacements” they key the W1070 in the lineup because it still sells well based on its reputation.
While there are similarities, the BenQ HT4050 pushes the envelop a good bit, compared to the W1070 and HT1075. Most notably it does that by adding CFI, aka “smooth motion” a feature that’s great for sports, is “ok” (my personal take) for some normal HDTV, and is not a feature I recommend for movie viewing, because it creates that “soap opera” affect, which means it inherently changes the feel of the movie, that is, it corrupts “the director’s intent.”
The HT4050 is bright enough to be considered a good home entertainment projector – able to play where there is some ambient light, but it’s not particularly bright claiming 2000 lumens, a bit low for today’s home entertainment projectors. On the other hand, with 2000 lumens it’s got enough to do a respectable, but not bright job on a typical 100″ diagonal screen for 3D viewing. More on that elsewhere in this review. Speaking of brightness, BenQ is pushing the max lumens they can out of this projector lamp. I say that because at full power, BenQ only rates the lamp 2000 hours, which is lower than almost any of the competition. Some claim 4000 or even 5000 hours at full power.
As part of being a home entertainment projector, as expected the HT4050 has a built in speaker – a fairly hefty 10 watt one. Ok, it’s no Home Theater surround sound system, but it will give you some decent sound, at a reasonably loud level for those action flicks. Still, get yourself a sound system if you want the whole experience.
Overall, I’ve logged more than 60 hours to date on the HT4050, and will continue to watch it in action as I write up this full review over the next few days. Overall, the experience was very pleasing. There’s lots to like about the HT4050, but let’s say that in some ways, for the $1399 price, I was “hoping for more.” Perhaps what I really was hoping to find was a true replacement for the aging, and $1000 more expensive BenQ W7500. Alas, it didn’t turn out as hoped.
OK, let’s generate a list of some of the highlights, and then it will be time to turn to our Special Features pages, to see discuss some of the interesting strengths (or even weaknesses).
The short list:
In the following pages we’ll consider all of these, and a lot more, with sections on the hardware and menus, picture quality, performance, and a summary that also considers the value proposition compared to the competition, including other BenQ models.
Did you use the pixel enhancer in the advanced menu to try to increase the sharpness of the picture? Was wondering how well that worked. You mentioned the Epson sharpness enhancer, but only mentioned/showed standard sharpness adjustment on the Benq HT4050. Thanks
Hi, how’s the rainbow effect? Would you recommend this projector over the epson 3500 for a rainbow effect sensible user? Thanks.
I am, I believe fairly typical for someone rainbow sensitive. I see them, but they don’t fatigue me, etc. true 5x or 6x wheels have very minimal rainbows and I could live with those. the 4050, though, in the US and other 60 cycle (hz) power areas drops down from 6x to only 4x. For me, I was seeing more rainbows than would make me happy. For that reason alone I’d pass on the HT4050.
As to the HC3500, that would be a good alternative for the rainbow sensitive. If you are really looking for best picture around that price – in a home theater projector (rather than home entertainment, you might look for either the Panasonic PT-AE8000 or, if you can find one, a refurbished Epson 5020UB (predecessor to the 5030UB). The 5030UB was only the slightest bit better than the 5020ub, until the Super-resolution upgrade came out for the 5030UB, separating the two models by a greater amount. But I’d personally take a 5020UB over the older PT-AE8000 (unless you are going widescreen, such as 2.35:1, in which case the PT-AE8000 has lens memory. The Epson UB’s have the best black levels far better than the 3500 or 4050, and slightly better than the Panasonic. If you can find a refurb 5020UB, you get the same 2 year warranty with 2 years of replacement program, that comes with new projectors, so unlike most refurbs you aren’t taking on greater risk. -art
Thanks for your insightful advice. I’ll try to get an epson ub.
Thanks for the review – couple questions:
1) The user manual for the HT4050 has a table with offsets – for a 100″ diagonal it says you can get up to 13.5″ offset (27%), do you think that is correct?
2) Seems like lots of projectors are including “High Altitude” modes these days, can you comment on the fan noise using this mode?
Hi Matt, First my apologies – as mentioned on one page of the review, you can find the offset on a different page – but I never put it in there. I’m on vacation right now, but I will get it in there. For lens shift offset I always pull the info from the manual. Historically I sometimes find a bit of sloppyness – such as saying for a 100 in screen the projector can be as close as, say 10 feet 2, and find out it’s more like 10 foot 1… Can’t remember when I saw a major error, but I would advise to try not to cut it exactly to the edge of the range, in case the quoted number is off by an inch or so.
As to High Altitude mode, you are right – I haven’t been addressing that, primarily on the basis of almost all High Altitude modes scream at you. Best guidance though is if a projector is average quiet at full power, it’s probably average in terms of how loud it is compared to other projectors when comparing High Altitude modes.
Numbers can be misleading at times. some projectors are loudest if you are in front of the projector, others loudest around the sides, but also the vertical component comes into play. -art
Love my HT4050 but when I play 3D it plays in 24fps. It seems to be locked in film mode. Is there a way to unlock this mode so I can run it off? Even when I choose User 1 (custom) it is locked.
© 2017 Projector Reviews