Projector Reviews

1080p Home Theater Projector Comparison Report – Image Quality12

Optoma HD20

With the HD20 AI operating, the HD20 can do some very nice dark blacks. But the visible action of ImageAI I find to be sufficiently noticeable that I recommended not using it. After turning it off, you are left with a basic DLP. It’s going to do slightly better blacks than the other two $999 projectors, but the rest of the field will best it.

Panasonic PT-AE4000

Winner! The PT-AE4000 really should be in the next group of projectors when one speaks of black levels. The black level performance of the PT-AE4000 is noticeably better than than all but one other projector in this class, and both blow away most of the others. The Panny is the most expensive projector in this class, and when it comes to black level performance, this is a true ultra-high contrast projector (though hardly the best). When separating the men from the boys, in black levels, the Panny is definitely one of the men. Nothing wrong with the dark shadow detail either. Not the very best, but close, definitely a bit better than the Epson 8100.

Samsung SP-A600

I was disappointed with the black level performance of the Samsung. It really didn’t do any better than most of the lower cost DLPs, and it’s blacks are no match for the several hundred dollar less Mitsubishi HC3800. Shadow detail, on the other hand, was very good.

Sanyo PLV-Z700

While the Sanyo’s shadow detail was very good, In the review, I wrote of being slightly disappointed with the black level performance of the Sanyo Z700. Not bad mind you, and better than the least expensive projectors in this class, including the three $999 DLPs. Still, it’s not much better than the best of those.

Sharp XV-Z15000

Great black level performance! The Sharp XV-Z15000 is perhaps the best of the projectors in this class. The other one, of course, is the PT-AE4000. I’m not sure which has the edge. I had indicated last year, that the Sharp was at least the equal to the older PT-AE3000, but the PT-AE4000 did slightly improve black levels over its predecessor. Let’s call them more different than better worse, and together, they are at the head of the Class.

Viewsonic Pro8100

Not bad at blacks. Definitely no match for the two champs, but should be about in the middle of the rest. Most likely the older Pro8100 is not quite a match for the Epson Home Cinema 8100 or the Mitsubishi HC3800, but it still will best the entry level DLP projetors and should be at least as good as the Sanyo PLV-Z700. Shadow detail, on the other hand was particularly good, at least compared to the competition almost two years ago.

Vivitek H1080FD

The almost twin to the BenQ W1000, the Vivitek is the better of the two in terms of blacks performance. This is most likely due to the faster color wheel, of the Vivitek, and lower lumens. It should, however come up a little short of the Optoma HD20. Shadow detail was in plentiful supply, as is typical of projectors with modest black level performance.

Above, from Men In Black with the Epson Home Cinema 8100, and below it, Aeon Flux on the Vivitek H1080FD.

two consecutive frames (I can’t remember which was first) before/after a lightning flash. Projector: Mitsubishi HC5500.


Bottom Line: If your budget won’t let you go over $2,000, and you’re planning a room that has good lighting control, and you want really dark blacks, then your two top choices are the Sharp XV-Z15000 and the Panasonic PT-AE4000. If room conditions or other factors reduce the importance of that next step in black level performance, then it’s the Mitsubishi and the Epson. The rest are all very entry level at blacks even though there’s still enough differences to notice.